The WhimWham

The surreal side of everyday life

  • Home
  • About
  • The INTP Yahoo Group
  • KaoticControl
May 13th, 2008

Attack of the Clones as type study

Dion in General Musings

If The Phantom Menace portrayed the tension between Introverted and Extraverted Thinking (i.e. Ti and Te), then Attack of the Clones explores Extraverted versus Introverted Feeling (i.e. Fe vs. Fi).

Fe emphasises our duties and obligations within our respective social roles. As a Jedi, Obi-Wan has a duty that goes beyond his own personal feelings—he is a Jedi first and an individual second. On the other hand, Fi transcends these roles, freeing us from the context of whatever role we’re playing at the time: the guiding principle instead is what we personally feel is right—this is embodied by Anakin’s choices in the film.

These are the functions of Fe and Fi as acted-out within the psyche of an INTP, however. Fe is the Anima/Animus, being positive and idealised, whereas Fi is the Demonic Personality, being steeped in the darkest of connotations. It’s personal bonds that keep leading Anakin down the path of the Dark Side because he’s ignoring his larger duties and obligations.

One scene in particular makes this dichotomy quite plain: Anakin, Obi-Wan and Padme are chasing Count Dooku on Geonosis when Padme falls out of their ship. Anakin demands that they fly back to get her, but Obi-Wan bites back: “Don’t let your personal feelings get in the way!” He then asks “What do you think Padme would do, were she in your position?” to which Anakin must admit, “She would do her duty.” Padme, of course, is Fe as the Anima. (See my earlier post on The Phantom Menace.)

Beyond all this, Te (as the Opposing Personality) gets another beating, this time as a political philosophy: when Anakin advocates what is essentially a benevolent dictatorship, his reasoning is simply, “If it works…” Meanwhile, Dex’s commentary on the difference between knowledge and wisdom can easily be interpreted as Te vs. Ti.

There’s more, but I need to ponder it further…

Tags: Anima/Animus, Demonic Personality, Extraverted Feeling, Extraverted Thinking, Hero/Heroine, INTP, Introverted Feeling, Introverted Thinking, Opposing Personality, Star Wars
no comment
April 15th, 2008

Brazil as ENTP psychodrama, part 7

Dion in General Musings

The Trickster archetype is one of deception and moral ambiguity. We’re never quite sure of whose side the Trickster is on (if they’re on any side at all).

The character that embodies this archetype in Brazil is Jill — the real Jill, not the dream Jill. Is she a terrorist? Can she be trusted? Neither Sam nor the audience are really sure.

For ENTPs, the Trickster is Introverted Feeling (Fi), the function of personal values. As a Hero, Fi is humanitarian and universal, but as a Trickster, it’s much harder to trust.

Jill, at the end of the day, cares about people as human beings, symbolising Fi. She is in direct contrast to the Puella, Sam’s mother, who cares more about social status (Fe). Note that, in an Oedipal moment, Sam actually dreams that his mother looks so young that she appears to be Jill — the two characters are two sides of the same coin.

In the final part: Extraverted Sensation (Se) as Demonic Personality…

Tags: Brazil, ENTP, ESTP, Introverted Feeling, Trickster
no comment

Recent Posts

    • Obligatory Rocktober post
    • Peter Gabriel and the Olympic Spirit
    • Midnight Oil: 10 - 1
    • Rick Wright is dead
    • Winter 2008 playlist

Recent Comments

  • 28.09 | Recent Links Tagged With "blackfield" - JabberTags… in no-man: schoolyard ghosts
  • 19.09 | Kathleen in Midnight Oil: 10 - 1
  • 19.09 | Kathleen in Midnight Oil: 10 - 1
  • 19.09 | Dion in Midnight Oil: 10 - 1
  • 19.09 | Kathleen in Midnight Oil: 10 - 1

Search

Blogroll

    • Dion at the Flicks
    • MikeFitz with overflow bit set…
    • Teacakery

Archives

    • October 2008
    • September 2008
    • August 2008
    • July 2008
    • June 2008
    • May 2008
    • April 2008
    • March 2008
    • February 2008
    • January 2008
    • December 2007

Categories

    • General Musings
    • Movies
    • Music
    • Site News

Tag Cloud

  • ESTP party ENFP Bulldogs Hero/Heroine WordPress outings Extraverted Sensation Pink Floyd concerts photos Brazil Peter Gabriel Anima/Animus video Introverted Thinking INTP Star Wars Introverted iNtuition NRL Opposing Personality Trickster Extraverted iNtuition playlists The Police Eels Steven Wilson Christianity injury 1980s Porcupine Tree religion dining celebrity meetups life Toto uni get a job Extraverted Feeling ENTP bizarre news Tom Petty politics Olympics

Meta

    • Log in
    • Entries RSS
    • Comments RSS
    • WordPress.org
© 2008 Wired by The WhimWham
Dezzain Studio
Nature Pictures | Bamboo Blinds